Some HomePod and Siri Realities

June 21, 2018 by Gabe | [mmd] |

The HomePod isn’t a complicated device to use. In fact, it can be frustratingly simple. My initial setup met my expectations for all new Apple hardware. It’s elegant, simple, and it feels like magic when it works.

HomePod

With that first juice of electricity, a new HomePod quickly latches onto an adjacent iPhone. Its first moments of life are a bit pedestrian, which is a relief from most of my other technology. The HomePod retrieves WiFi settings and user profiles from the iPhone and that just leaves the user with a simple task of testing their own competency at speaking a command to play music. HomePod wisely created a playlist of my favorite music as a test. Who doesn’t enjoy a playlist made from their own favorite songs and artists?

From the start, the HomePod is simple, with all of the complexity, controls, and options hidden from the user. I mean literally hidden. The controls on the top of the HomePod are nearly invisible and amount to little more than a plus and minus symbol for volume. The real meat of the HomePod control is only available in the Home and Music apps on an iPhone.

The HomePod was automatically added to my Home app. I already had a few HomeKit devices in my house but almost never used the Home app. For my Hue bulbs I preferred the Phillips Hue app. To get at the HomePod settings I tapped the HomePod tile in the Home app and then tapped "Details." From there I could adjust the few settings available in the HomePod. I think most people will care about the "Use Listening History" option. I chose to allow this but if you don't want your kid destroying your Apple Music recommendations with HomePod requests then you may want to change this.

Settings

It still feels weird that access to HomePod is through the Home app. Although many settings are available as voice commands, I think this points to Apple's vision of the HomePod as a home control hub and not just a music player. I can get behind the HomePod as a home automation device, but if Apple is serious about the Home app being a portal to the device, then these blank stares from the app need to be refreshed.

Empty Screens

Music control on the HomePod is available through the Music app instead of the Home app. This feels a bit more natural but can also be somewhat confusing. I never really used the Music app for multiple sources and it was a nice surprise to see how well this is integrated into iOS 11. I pulled down Control Center and tapped the AirPlay icon on the music control to see all of the destinations I could play to. Tapping each one brings up controls that allows me to change them independently.

Multiple Sources

This is different from using the AirPlay controls for my iPhone to play to other devices. That's also possible with the HomePod.

AirPlay

One of the surprising discoveries for me was how well Siri works on my iPhone to play music to my HomePod over AirPlay. Siri on iPhone can also be used as remote control for the HomePod with options to start, stop, skip, and adjust volume.

Siri AirPlay

I quickly adjusted to using the Music app to control the HomePod (when not using my voice). The same details and controls available when playing on the iPhone are there when playing from the HomePod.

Music Details and Control

Having access to my entire music collection, including playlists is really great. I didn't pay for Amazon Prime Music so we often could not play songs we wanted on the Echo with a simple voice command. The HomePod finds music like a champ.

Now on to the two things that make the HomePod worth the money for me: The speakers and the microphone.

The HomePod sounds good. I own several Sonos speakers and I think the HomePod sounds much better than the Play:1 and slightly better than the Play:5. The low-tones are fairly pronounced but don't vibrate the speaker and the highs don't sound like a tin-can. We've been using an Amazon Echo and an Amazon Show around the house and my family immediately preferred the HomePod for music. I didn't even have to convince them to use it.

What I find the most impressive about the HomePod, even more than the great speakers and the small size, is the incredible sensitivity of the microphone. I always felt like I was yelling at the Amazon Echo, but not with the HomePod. I can speak normally, even when music is playing from across the room. We have an open format kitchen and living room. From the other side of the space, and not looking in the direction of the HomePod, I can issue commands in a conversational voice. It's still shocking that it works this well.

I was even able to give a voice command to the HomePod from another room without yelling. This only worked when music wasn't playing, but it's something that the Echo still can't do.

Siri and HomePod

My history with Siri has been pretty rough and I'd call myself a realistic fan of Alexa on the Echo. I like using voice assistants but they are nowhere near good enough. They are still an impressive toy, even if they aren't vital.

My kid and I took turns quizzing our robots. We started with some relatively difficult fact-based questions. We already knew both devices could give us the weather or tell us how to spell a word. We wanted to see how it handled some things that were more difficult to search for on the internet.

“How long is Massachusetts”

Siri gave me the elevation while Alexa correctly gave me the length of the state. It's a weird fact but point goes to Alexa.

“How tall is Glenn Close”

Both got this right. I don't actually care about Glenn Close but it seemed like a fun question.

“How old is the oldest human”

Siri told me the the oldest person was 122 years old. Alexa told me the oldest person was 117 years old. At that age, 5 years seems irrelevant unless you are that birthday girl. I think the difference is that Siri reports the oldest person ever and Alexa reports the oldest person still alive.

“How many calories in a gallon of mayo”

Siri couldn’t answer. Alexa tried to explain to me that gallons measure volume and can not be converted to calories.

“How many calories in a gallon of mayonnaise”

Siri provided the answer as 15,511 dietary calories. Alexa, once again, tried to explain units to me. I thought it was interesting that the contraction for mayonnaise, arguably more commonly used than the full name, is what threw off Siri.

"How long would it take to drive to Worcester Mass"

Both Siri and Alexa got this right and included adjustments for current traffic. Siri went the extra mile and indicated the primary highway it was assuming for the trip. This is both useful and impressive. It's useful because Worcester has some excellent beer bars. It's impressive because it understood one of the most difficult to pronounce city names.

"What song goes 'I put the lime in the coconut and shook it all up'"

While Alexa provided a song and album art for the Harry Nilsson song, HomePod simply told me that wasn't something it could do. If you were hoping Siri could help you with a bellyache, you'd be wrong.

For basic math, something that is surprisingly useful around our house, both robots gave accurate answers without needing any clarification. For multiple operations Siri and Alexa processes from right to left. Both are also annoyingly verbose and repeat the calculation with the answer.

What is 12 x 4 + 7”

55

"What's 12+4÷2"

14

We asked both robots who played Elasti-girl in the Incredibles. Siri tried to find a song and Alexa simply told me it didn't know.

My kid was in charge of asking for jokes. She preferred Siri's dumb jokes over Alexa's but both paled in comparison to her father's.

Then there are a few things that Siri on the HomePod is much better at. Most of it has to do with Apple services so it's not a big surprise. Siri was much better at telling details about upcoming calendar items, like start times.

"Hey Siri, what time is golf this weekend"

Siri gave me the exact right time from my calendar.

"Hey Siri, make a note that the couch is 72 inches long"

Being able to take notes with the HomePod is pretty wonderful. I find that even more useful than Reminders, which also works well.

Siri on the HomePod is unable to access all kinds of personal data. It refused to tell me how many steps I walked or how far away my wife was. I can appreciate this extra layer of security even if I kind of wish it could do it. Siri on the HomePod also can not start phone calls, which seems like a good idea when I consider that anyone in my house can use the device.

I've been far more impressed by a Siri constrained to voice responses than Siri on my iPhone. This assistant provides more valuable feedback when it can't simply show me a list of Google search results or a Wikipedia snippet.

The one major gripe I have about Siri over Alexa is the extra effort to say "Hey Siri." It seems minor, but I forget the "hey" part regularly and then have to repeat the request. Siri also adds a lot of filler words in the responses. These lengthen the response without providing any value. I'd rather have Siri say "I don't know" instead of "Sorry, I can't seem to find that."

I've read complaints that "Hey Siri" triggers multiple Apple devices in the same room but this has never happened to me. My iPhone will often light up when I issue the command for the HomePod but the HomePod always wins. I suspect this was fixed with the recent AirPlay 2 update for the HomePod and I'm benefiting from that now.

Home in the HomePod

While it felt weird to use the Home app to change the HomePod settings, I now see where Apple might be headed. The HomePod can act as a hub for HomeKit enabled devices and is obviously a great voice control device for these devices. With iOS 12, Siri can become an automation hub for my entire house.

I'm still not a power-user of the Home app. It feels confused. It feels sparse and cluttered at the same time.

Home

After connecting and configuring my Hue bulbs and hubs with HomeKit I started arranging my "House" with rooms and zones. I have no idea why I would want different zones but now I can turn on lights or set scenes in different rooms using HomePod. I was able to do this with the Amazon Echo already but because the HomePod microphone is so much more sensitive, it feels more natural asking it to adjust the lights when I walk into the room.

Conclusion

The HomePod was a gift. I wouldn't have bought it for myself. But I love it. Within a day I already wanted a second HomePod. Within a week I had stopped using my Amazon Echo devices.

I plan to replace all of my Sonos speakers with HomePods. I'm in no rush but I think Siri automation in iOS 12 will further catalyze this change.

Unlike every other Apple device, I think the marketing for the HomePod is the worst part of the product. While the purpose of the HomePod is right there in the name, Apple seems to be selling this as a high-end speaker instead of a home assistant hub with an endless music catalog. Maybe that will change with iOS 12 and Siri improvements.

tags

Older articles

  1. WWDC 2018 Idle Thoughts

    June 08, 2018 by Gabe | [mmd] |

    Let’s see if I can do a Dave Pell style post.

    1. I actually liked Snow Leopard more than Leopard, so a year of improvements is just fine by me.
    2. 2018 feels like the year of “sorry we ruined your family life” from Apple.
    3. I still don’t want a ...
  2. Messages in iCloud

    June 01, 2018 by Gabe | [mmd] |

    I immediately turned on iCloud storage for Messages with the latest iOS update. I liked this succinct summary by Paul Horowitz over at OS X Daily. That’s a lot of storage moved to iCloud.

    iCloud Storage

  3. iCab Dark Mode

    June 01, 2018 by Gabe | [mmd] |

    Dark Mode

    Another update to iCab that makes me wish it was my full time browser. Dark mode is a terrific new option with iCab for iOS. It renders pages in something like an inverted color scheme but it's more clever than that. Backgrounds are dark, text is light, and graphic ...

  4. My Mac Menu Bar for June 2018

    June 01, 2018 by Gabe | [mmd] |

    Affiliate: This basically converts Amazon and iTunes links on my clipboard to affiliate links. It’s simple but it works.

    Default Folder X: The “Save as...” window is so much better with this app. The menu bar app provides a convenient way to navigate to recent and favorite locations. I ...

  5. ForecastAdvisor and Weather Services

    May 31, 2018 by Gabe | [mmd] |

    One of my character flaws is that I obsess about weather apps and forecast services. Maybe it's because I don't follow any sports so that only leaves weather to make small talk in elevators. Whatever the reason, I own a lot of weather apps. I fell out of ...

  6. iCloud Sync for DEVONthink

    May 30, 2018 by Gabe | [mmd] |

    As of last week the single largest use I had for Dropbox was DEVONthink syncing. I have 10 active databases all syncing thousands of documents between my Mac version and the iOS version. With DEVONthink’s encrypted sync, I rest pretty comfortably knowing that my data is guarded against Dropbox ...

  7. 1Password 7 for Mac

    May 22, 2018 by Gabe | [mmd] |

    This is a big update for 1Password on the Mac. Not only does the applicaiton look great but one of my favorite features is getting a lot more useful: Secure notes now support Markdown formatting!

    I have a lot of secure notes in 1Password. I don't just need to ...

  8. Some Drafts 5 Links and Tips

    May 22, 2018 by Gabe | [mmd] |

    Drafts 5 has been out for a few weeks and I've read a lot of interesting ideas about the note app. I've also cleaned up and trimmed down (and then expanded) a bunch of my actions for the app since I last wrote about it. Now comes a ...

  9. FoldingText 3 Announced

    May 15, 2018 by Gabe | [mmd] |

    FoldingText is quite the impressive text editor. It was started by the same folks behind TaskPaper and was spun out as a more powerful text editor with task management features.

    A post in the support forum is now talking about the future of this unique beast. 2018 might just be ...